同行评议周 2021: 同行评审中的身份
发布时间:2025-08-25 阅读数:41 发布:学术出版研究中心
2021年,Peer Review Week 的主题首次通过社区投票确定为“同行评审中的身份(Identity in Peer Review)”,活动时间为9月20日至24日。本届活动聚焦个人与社会身份因素——如性别、种族和文化背景——如何影响评审实践和体验,同时探讨如何推动更具多样性、公平性与包容性的同行评审体系,以提升学术社区的整体公正性与参与感。

其活动内容汇总如下:
Table of Contents
目录
Online Events 在线活动
BLOGs 博客
VIDEOS 视频
other online publications (e-books, online guides, editorials, protocols, and data sets)
其他在线出版物(电子书、在线指南、社论、协议和数据集)
Other Activities (Quizzes, Surveys, Podcasts, and Audio Clips)
其他活动(测验、调查、播客和音频片段)
Online Events
在线活动
Monday, September 20th 9 月 20 日星期一
Exploring identities in peer review: A look at author, reviewer, and journal perspectives
探索同行评审中的身份:作者、评审人和期刊视角的探讨
Webinar by Editage Editage 网络研讨会
Introducing Peer Review 介绍同行评审
Webinar by Charlesworth Author Services
Charlesworth Author Services 网络研讨会
EASE panel discussion for Peer Review Week 2021
EASE 同行评审周圆桌讨论会
Online event by EASE EASE 在线活动
Celebrating Peer Review 庆祝同行评审
Online event by The Lancet
《柳叶刀》在线活动
Twitter chat with the journal CHEST
CHEST 期刊的 Twitter 聊天
Online event by the journal Chest
CHEST 期刊的在线活动
(Throughout the week, the journal CHEST will be tweeting questions relating to the topic of Peer Review and responses received from many of the journal’s peer reviewers)
(在这一周中,CHEST 期刊将发布与同行评审相关的问答问题,并收到许多期刊同行评审者的回复)
Tuesday, September 21st 周二,9 月 21 日
Virtual Panel: Finding a Place in the Peer Review Process
虚拟圆桌:在同行评审过程中找到位置
Online event by the Peer Review Week Steering Committee
由同行评审周指导委员会举办的在线活动
Ask the Experts: Identity in Peer Review
专家答疑:同行评审中的身份问题
Webinar by Charlesworth Author Services
Charlesworth Author Services 网络研讨会
Author and reviewer experiences: Building a bridge of empathy
作者和审稿人的体验:搭建同理心之桥
Webinar by Editage Editage 网络研讨会
Diversity in Peer Review 同行评议的多样性
Online event by The Lancet
《柳叶刀》在线活动
What role are Early Career Researchers playing in peer review, and what role should they play?
早期职业研究人员在同行评审中扮演着什么角色,他们应该扮演什么角色?
Twitter chat by Lightoller, LLC
Lightoller, LLC 的 Twitter 聊天
ORCID Workshop for Researchers: Update your ORCID Record to Save Time and Get Credit in Funding Applications, Research Reporting, and Publishing
研究人员 ORCID 工作坊:更新 ORCID 记录以节省时间并在资助申请、研究报告和出版中获得认可
Online event by Lyrasis Lyrasis 举办的在线活动
Effective Peer Review 有效的同行评审
Online event by ASLO ASLO 在线活动
CSE Connect
Online Event by the Council of Science Editors
科学编辑委员会在线活动
TAA Committee for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Town Hall on Peer Review
促进多样性和包容性委员会关于同行评审的镇 hall 会议
Online Event by the Textbook & Academic Authors Association
Textbook &学术作者协会举办的在线活动
Wednesday, September 22nd
2021 年 9 月 22 日星期三
Behind the scenes of peer review
同行评审背后的台前幕后
Online event by the South African Journal of Science
南非科学杂志举办的在线活动
Things You Need to Know About Peer Review
你需要了解的关于同行评审的事情
Online event by Charlesworth Author Services
查尔斯沃思作者服务举办的在线活动
The Stages of Peer Review
同行评审的阶段
Webinar by Charlesworth Author Services
Charlesworth Author Services 网络研讨会
Launching ‘Review Assistant’: An AI-powered Tool for Peer Reviewers
发布“审稿助手”:一种为同行评审员设计的 AI 辅助工具
Online event by Enago Enago 在线活动
Openness or Confidentiality in Peer Review
同行评审中的开放性与保密性
Online event by The American Physical Society
美国物理学会举办的在线活动
African Perspectives on Peer Review: a Roundtable Discussion
非洲视角下的同行评审:圆桌讨论
Online event by AfricArXiv, Eider Africa, TCC Africa, and PREreview
AfricArXiv、Eider Africa、TCC Africa 和 PREreview 主办的在线活动
Behind the scenes: How a peer reviewer reviews a manuscript
幕后揭秘:同行评审员如何评审手稿
Webinar by Editage Editage 网络研讨会
Identity in Peer Review 同行评议中的身份
Online event by Sense about Science and IOP Publishing
Sense about Science 和 IOP Publishing 主办的在线活动
Connecting Mosaics of Scholarly Identity Through Metadata: The Roles of Publishers and Service Providers
通过元数据连接学者身份拼图:出版商和服务提供商的作用
Online event by Scholastica
Scholastica 举办的在线活动
Peer Review in Blockchain Research
区块链研究中的同行评审
Online event by The JBBA
在线活动,由 JBBA 举办
Finding the Right Peer Reviewers
找到合适的同行评审者
Online event by Altum 在线活动,由 Altum 举办
Thursday, September 23rd
星期四,9 月 23 日
Does Recognition Strengthen Peer Reviewer Identity?
认可能否强化同行评审者的身份?
Online event by ReviewerCredits and Edanz
由 ReviewerCredits 和 Edanz 举办的在线活动
The Future of Preprint Peer Review
预印本同行评审的未来
Online event by EMBL-EBI and Europe PMC
由 EMBL-EBI 和 Europe PMC 举办的在线活动
Peer Reviewers and Transparency in Peer Review
同行评审者与同行评审的透明度
Webinar by Charlesworth Author Services
Charlesworth Author Services 网络研讨会
Should early career researchers be appointed as peer reviewers
早期职业研究人员是否应该被任命为同行评审员
Webinar by Editage Editage 网络研讨会
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Scholarly Publishing
学术出版中的多样性和包容性
Online event by Aries Systems
Aries Systems 在线活动
A researcher’s guide to navigating peer review
研究人员的同行评审导航指南
Webinar by Luigi Longobardi for AIP Publishing
Luigi Longobardi 为 AIP Publishing 举办的网络研讨会
Lived Experience in Peer Review
同行评审中的个人经历
Online event by The Lancet
《柳叶刀》在线活动
Good Peer Review With All Aspects
全面的同行评议
Online event by EASE, Turkish Regional Chapter Panel
EASE 土耳其区域分会线上研讨会
The Road to Double-Anonymous Peer Review: From Idealization to Implementation
双盲同行评审的道路:从理想到实施
By the Council of Science Editors
由科学编辑学会主办
ISMTE Peer Review Week Early Career Meet Up
ISMTE 同行评审周 新晋学者见面会
Online event by ISMTE 由 ISMTE 在线举办
Friday, September 24th 星期五,9 月 24 日
A talk Cum Discussion on Identity in Peer Review
关于审稿中身份的演讲与讨论
Online event by Chitkara University Publications
昌克拉大学出版社举办的在线活动
Responding to Revise-and-Resubmit and Rejection
回应修改重投与拒稿
Webinar by Charlesworth Author Services
Charlesworth Author Services 网络研讨会
Peer Review and the Pandemic
同行评审与疫情
Twitter chat by F1000Research
F1000Research 的 Twitter 聊天
Identity in Research Infrastructure: An Overview of How Identity Is Managed in Scholarly Infrastructure
研究基础设施中的身份:学术基础设施中身份管理概览
Online event by HighWire HighWire 主办的在线活动
Does WHO You Are Influence HOW You Conduct Peer Review?
你的身份会影响你的同行评审方式吗?
Webinar by Editage Editage 网络研讨会
Blog Posts
博客文章
NEW: Exploring the Human Dimension of Peer Review
新增内容:探索同行评审的人文维度
Blog by Guadalupe I. Lozano for DeGruyter
Guadalupe I. Lozano 在 DeGruyter 的博客
NEW: Identity in Peer Review: Peer Review Week 2021
新内容:同行评审中的身份:2021 年同行评审周
Blog by Julia T. Vilstrup Mouatt at Clarivate
Clarivate 的朱莉娅·T·维尔斯特·莫特博客
NEW: Peer Review Week 2021 – Opening up Peer Review at BMC
新内容:2021 年同行评审周 – BMC 开放同行评审
Blog by Darren Byrne & Roshan Ahmed at BMC
Darren Byrne & Roshan Ahmed 在 BMC 的博客
NEW: What? Me Review? 新动态:什么?我来审稿?
Blog by Casey Hooke for Sage Publishing
Sage 出版社的 Casey Hooke 博客
NEW: Six months of Transparent Peer Review at SAGE
新动态:SAGE 六个月的透明同行评审
Blog by Katrina Pickersgill at Sage Publishing
Sage Publishing 博客:Katrina Pickersgill
NEW: How to Minimise delays in Peer Review
如何尽量减少同行评审的延误
Blog by Dan Nunan for Sage Publishing
Sage Publishing 博客 由 Dan Nunan 编写
NEW: Fostering a More Diverse, Equitable and Inclusive Peer Review Process at SAGE
新内容:促进更具有多样、公平和包容性的同行评审过程——在施普林格·自然实现
Blog by Amanda Bockman, Julia Slater, Katie Gibson, and Sam Perkins at Sage Publishing
Sage Publishing 的 Amanda Bockman、Julia Slater、Katie Gibson 和 Sam Perkins 的博客
Including and valuing postdocs in peer review
包括并重视博士后在同行评审中的参与
Blog post by Gary McDowell of Lightoller, LLC
Lightoller, LLC 的 Gary McDowell 的博客文章
Peer Review Week 2021 – KeAi reviewers share their thoughts on this year’s theme
2021 同行评审周——KeAi 评审人分享今年主题的见解
Blog by KeAi – publishing company
KeAi 出版公司博客
Peer Review Week 2021: Interview with Craig S. Anderson
Peer Review Week 2021:对 Craig S. Anderson 的访谈
Blog by Karger Publishing
Karger Publishing 博客
The Case for Open Peer Review
开放同行评审的论据
Blog by kriyadocs 博客由 kriyadocs 编写
Embracing the role of the reviewer: developing diverse, equitable, and inclusive peer review teams
承担评审人的角色:培养多元、公平和包容的评审团队
Blog by SAGE Publishing SAGE Publishing 博客
Peer Review Week 2021: Identity in Peer Review
2021 同行评议周:同行评议中的身份问题
Blog by Simon Linacre of Cabells
Cabells 的 Simon Linacre 博客
One Nation, One Subscription
一国一订阅
Blog by Penprints Publication
Penprints Publication 博客
Prepublication Peer Review: An Underutilized Research Scrutiny Tool
预出版同行评审:一种未充分利用的科研审查工具
Blog by Tamer El-Sobky, Professor of Orthopedic Surgery, Consultant Pediatric Orthopedics
Tamer El-Sobky 博客,骨科教授,小儿骨科顾问
What’s Transparent Peer Review and How Can it Benefit You?
透明同行评审是什么以及它如何为您带来益处?
Blog by Helen Eassom, Wiley
Wiley 的 Helen Eassom 撰文
10 Things You Need to Know Before You Peer Review
在您进行同行评审前需要了解的 10 件事
Blog by Wiley Wiley 博客
Role of Identity in Peer Review- Moving Towards a Reliable System
身份在同行评审中的作用——迈向可靠的系统
Blog by Enago Enago 博客
Peer Review Survey: Reporting Your Experiences
同行评审调查:分享您的体验
Blog by the Royal Society
皇家学会博客
Blog post series about “Identity in Peer Review”
关于“同行评审中的身份”系列博客文章
Blog by Alexandra Hinz of De Gruyter
De Gruyter 的 Alexandra Hinz 博客
(Look for blog posts after 9/20/2021)
(请关注 9 月 20 日之后发布的博客文章)
The case for more diversity in peer review
更多元化的同行评审的重要性
Blog by Elsevier Elsevier 博客
(Available as of 9/20/2021)
(截至 2021 年 9 月 20 日)
My Journey through Peer Review Week 2021
我的 Peer Review Week 2021 之旅
Blog by Jayanthiny Kangatharan (European Acoustics Association)
Jayanthiny Kangatharan(欧洲声学协会)的博客
(Available as of 9/21/2021)
(截至 2021 年 9 月 21 日)
Peer Review Diversity in Action
同行评审多样性在行动
Blog by Elsevier Elsevier 博客
(Available as of 9/21/2021)
(截至 2021 年 9 月 21 日)
Open Reviewer Identities: Full Steam Ahead or Proceed with Caution?
匿名评审员身份:全速前进还是谨慎行事?
Blog by Veronique Kiermer and Alison Mudditt for Scholarly Kitchen
博文中,Veronique Kiermer 和 Alison Mudditt 为 Scholarly Kitchen 写道
(Available as of 9/21/2021)
(截至 2021 年 9 月 21 日)
How to Make Peer Review More Diverse and Inclusive
如何让同行评审更加多元化和包容
Blog by Medical Research Council
Medical Research Council 博文
(Available as of 9/22/2021)
(截至 2021 年 9 月 22 日)
The How and the Why of Collecting Identity Data
收集身份数据的必要性和理由
Blog by Kristen Overstreet from Origin Reports
Kristen Overstreet 来自 Origin Reports 的博客
(Available as of 9/22/2021)
(截至 2021 年 9 月 22 日)
How to improve reviewer diversity? A toolkit for editors-Part I
如何提高审稿人多样性?编辑工具包(一)
Blog by Elsevier Elsevier 博客
(Available as of 9/22/2021)
(截至 2021 年 9 月 22 日)
How to improve reviewer diversity? A toolkit for editors-Part II
如何提高审稿人多样性?编辑工具包——第二部分
Blog by Elsevier Elsevier 博客
(Available as of 9/23/2021)
(截至 2021 年 9 月 23 日)
Introducing Open Peer Review Content in the Web of Science
在 Web of Science 中引入开放同行评审内容
(Available as of 9/23/2021)
(截至 2021 年 9 月 23 日)
Videos
视频
NEW: Peer Review 2021: What Does Identity and Inclusion in Peer Review Really Mean?
新内容:2021 同行评审:同行评审中的身份与包容性究竟意味着什么?
Video by George Kimble at Hindawi Limited
乔治·金布尔在 hindawi 有限公司制作的视频
To Unmask “Identity in Peer Review” or Not?
是否揭露“同行评审中的身份”?
Series of Videos by Enago
Enago 制作的一系列视频
A series of eight videos on one page. Titles include: Moving Toward a Reliable Peer Reviewed System; An Ideal Peer Review System; Anonymous Peer-Reviewing; Perks of a Double-Blinded System; It’s a Practice of Ethics; Advantages of Revealing Identities; No Conflict of Interest; and Identity in Peer Review
一页上的八段视频系列。标题包括:迈向可靠的同行评审系统;理想的同行评审系统;匿名同行评审;双盲系统的优点;这是一种伦理实践;揭示身份的优势;无利益冲突;同行评审中的身份
Peer Review and Data Validation
同行评审和数据验证
Recorded webinar/video by CITI Program
CITI 项目录制的网络研讨会/视频
(Available for viewing as of September 20th)
(截至 2021 年 9 月 20 日可供查看)
Get Answers to All the Prevalent Questions Related to “Identity in Peer Review”
解答所有关于“同行评审中的身份”方面的常见问题
Video by Enago Enago 制作的视频
(Available for viewing as of September 20th)
(截至 2021 年 9 月 20 日可供查看)
Running a Great Grant Peer Review
开展一次成功的资助同行评审
Video by Altum Altum 制作的视频
(Complete the form to receive the replay video link)
(填写表格以获取回放视频链接)
Select Crowd Review: Enabling the Intelligence of the Crowd to Review Scientific Papers Faster and Better
众包评审:利用群众的智慧更快更好地评审科学论文
Video by Filestage Filestage 制作的视频
Increasing Transparency and Trust in Preprints: Steps Journals Can Take
提高预印本透明度和信任度:期刊可以采取的措施
Free recorded webinar by Scholastica
Scholastica 提供的免费录制网络研讨会
Transparent Peer Review 透明同行评审
Video by Wiley 威利公司制作的视频
IJSPT Reviewer Workshop IJSPT 审稿人研讨会
Video by The International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy (IJSPT)
由《国际运动物理治疗杂志》(IJSPT)制作的视频
AGU Co-Reviewing Webinar 美国地球物理联合会联合审稿网络研讨会
Video by the American Geophysical Union
美国地球物理联合会制作的视频
Peer Review Week 2021: Interview with Craig S. Anderson
Peer Review Week 2021:对 Craig S. Anderson 的访谈
Video by by Karger Publishing
卡 arger 出版社制作的视频
Advancing the Science of Scientific Publishing – Peer Review Congress
推进科学出版的科学——同行评审大会
Virtual symposium recording by JAMA Network
JAMA 网络的虚拟研讨会录像
Performing Scientific Peer Review
科学同行评审
Recorded online training course by Karger Publishing
卡格尔出版社录制的在线培训课程
Other Online Publications
其他在线出版物
(E-books, online guides, editorials, protocols, articles and data sets)
(电子书、在线指南、社论、协议、文章和数据集)
NEW: Now More Than Ever: Reflections on the State and Importance of Peer Review
新内容:前所未有的时刻:关于同行评审状态及其重要性的反思
Editorial by Christopher P. Morley and Sam Grammer for STFM Journals
STFM 期刊的克里斯托弗·P·莫里和萨姆·格拉默的社论
NEW: Reviewer’s Checklist: Achieving Excellence in Peer Review
新内容:审稿人检查表:在同行评审中追求卓越
Checklist by Enago (requires email registration)
Enago 提供的检查清单(需要电子邮件注册)
Open Peer Review Data Sets
开放同行评审数据集
Data sets by The American Institute of Biological Sciences (for peer review researchers)
美国生物科学学会的数据集(供同行评审研究人员参考)
Journal Management Best Practices: Tales from the Trenches
最佳期刊管理实践:来自一线的故事
Learn how to refine your journal’s peer review processes, attract more quality submissions, make actionable strategic plans to further your publishing goals, and more in this free eGuide from Scholastica.
了解如何精炼您期刊的同行评审流程,吸引更多高质量投稿,制定切实可行的战略计划以进一步实现出版目标等。这一切都可以通过施拉科斯蒂卡提供的免费电子指南实现。
Peer Review: The Nuts and Bolts
同行评审:基本要素
Downloadable online guide by Sense About Science
Sense About Science 提供的可下载在线指南
Peer Review Week, 2021 同行评审周,2021
Editorial by Dianne King-McGavin for American Journal of Physiology
Dianne King-McGavin 为《美国生理学杂志》撰写的社论
5 Steps to Running a Successful Grant Peer Review
成功开展资助项目同行评审的五步法
E-book by Altum Altum 出品的电子书
Guide to Managing Peer Reviewers: Journal Editor Training Course
同行评审管理指南:期刊编辑培训课程
This Scholastica editor training course covers how to develop a reviewer management plan to improve the experience of peer reviewers working with your academic journal(s).
本 Scholastica 编辑培训课程涵盖了如何制定审稿人管理计划,以改善与贵刊合作的同行评审人的体验。
Ants-Review: A Privacy-Oriented Protocol for Incentivized Open Peer Reviews on Ethereum
蚂蚁审阅:以太坊上具有隐私导向激励开放同行评审的协议
Protocol by Bianca Trovò and Nazzareno Massari
Bianca Trovò和 Nazzareno Massari 的协议
Ninth International Congress on Peer Review and Scientific Publication: Call for Abstracts
第九届国际同行评审与科学出版大会:征文启事
Editorial by John P. A. Ioannidis, MD, DSc, et al. Published by JAMA Network
约翰·P·A·伊奥尼迪斯(MD,DSc)等人的编辑评论,发表于 JAMA 网络
Peer reviewing made easier: your questions answered
让同行评审更简单:您的问题解答
Article by Royal College of Psychiatrists / BJPsych Advances
皇家精神病学院文章 / BJPsych Advances
Other Activities 其他活动
(Quizzes, Surveys, Podcasts, and Audio Clips)
(测验、调查、播客和音频片段)
Peer Review Week Quiz 同行评审周测验
Online quiz by KnE Publishing
由 KnE 出版社举办的在线测验
COPE Peer Review Diversity Survey 2021
2021 年 COPE 同行评审多样性调查
Survey by COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics)
COPE(出版伦理委员会)调查
“Politics in Peer Review”
“同行评审中的政治”
Podcast by Jasmine Wallace and Carolyn deCourt for the Council of Science Editors
Council of Science Editors 的 Jasmine Wallace 和 Carolyn deCourt 的播客
Every Action Counts: The Importance of Building an Inclusive Reviewer Pool
每一行动都重要:构建包容性审稿人团队的重要性
Audio clip by Mare Meadows at Wiley
音频片段由 Wiley 的 Mare Meadows 提供
来源:https://archive.peerreviewweek.net/?page_id=1420
同行评议周 2016: 对评审的认可
2025-08-25
同行评议周 2019: 评审质量
2025-08-25
同行评议周 2017: 同行评审的透明性
2025-08-25
同行评议周 2018: 同行评审的多样性
2025-08-25